This place is a true "best kept secret". My favorite pizza in town is here. It may take a bit longer to receive a meal here compared to other chain places, but it's well worth it. I used to go...

This place is a true "best kept secret". My favorite pizza in town is here. It may take a bit longer to receive a meal here compared to other chain places, but it's well worth it. I used to go regularly when I lived in the southwest, but find it's still worth the drive now that I live in the northwest. And they've got an outstanding treat that cannot be found elsewhere called a "bongo"--they're delicious! It's a baked goodie -- pizza dough filled with cheese, sausage, spinach, and other yummy things, and it comes with a spicy dipping sauce--delicious! I often order these as an appetizer, perfect for sharing for two while waiting for the meal. And the staff are always friendly and attentive. I've never had anything but positive experiences whenever I've gone, and that's why I keep coming back. 

 

The pizza is fantastic (BBQ chicken) but the customer service I received was horrible. I ordered the pizza for pickup. I was told 30 minutes till it was done. I came 30 minutes later and was told...

The pizza is fantastic (BBQ chicken) but the customer service I received was horrible. I ordered the pizza for pickup. I was told 30 minutes till it was done. I came 30 minutes later and was told 10 minutes. No biggie. 40 minutes later I finally received my pizza and the I was fuming mad. Of course I did not get a discount or anything for my patience. 70 minutes to from order to they finally handing it to me. It will be a very long time till I go back.

Their pizza ia great.

Their pizza ia great.

The consensus of my group was that Plumberry's was the best pizza they ever had. But, I wasn't so enthusiastic. My pizza was good & heavy, but I just couldn’t find my way to...

The consensus of my group was that Plumberry's was the best pizza they ever had. But, I wasn't so enthusiastic. My pizza was good & heavy, but I just couldn’t find my way to share their love for my stocky sausage, tomato, cashew, mushroom, Canadian bacon, olive pizza.
Maybe my enthusiasm was tempered by the fact that they foolishly let me pick my own toppings. Anybody that knows me understands that I’m in no way mature enough for that. I mean cashews? That sounds like a huge risk. But, me being the way I am, how was I to resist such a non-traditional topping?
I think the short answer is that I’m going to have to try again, and again, and again until I get my choice just right. Plumberry’s is worth the effort, it’s the perfect platform for my circular gustatory experimentations.
5 pizza stars.