|
Ombudsman: Budget cuts hurt long-term care Kern's longstanding battle with the mosquito Read the complaint filed against Dr. Freesemann, others Tips to avoid hospital, school infections BPD: Drug cache found in Dr. Freesemann's home, motor home The budget dust settles: How did health programs fare? Prominent doctor arrested in drug investigation British campaign IDs nine types of heavy drinkers The latest budget compromise and health care Bako AIDS Project: $37,000 can go a long way August 06 September 06 October 06 November 06 December 06 January 07 February 07 March 07 April 07 May 07 June 07 July 07 August 07 September 07 October 07 November 07 December 07 January 08 February 08 March 08 April 08 May 08 June 08 July 08 August 08 September 08 October 08 Here's some sites I find useful and interesting: Some fun blogs I like, some health and some random: Got a blog or link to add to this list? Please let me know at ehagedorn@bakersfield.com.
RSS 2.0![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Share! |
|
|
Everything I need to know I learned from 'House'
Almost any night of the week you can have your pick of medical TV shows. You got your "Scrubs," "Grey's Anatomy" and "House." If reality TV is your thing, take your pick from "Untold Stories of the ER" on TLC and "Dr. 90210" on E!. Even the crime shows, like "Law and Order" and "CSI," break over into the health TV genre from time to time.
So it should come as no surprise that people are gleaning health information from these shows that they then rely on in real life. (Read "Shows raise awareness, but distort expectations" on the cover of Eye Street in Sunday's Californian.) A 2001 study from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention found that 52 percent of prime time TV viewers think the health information in the shows is accurate and 26 percent say prime time TV shows are among their top three sources for health information. While in some respects this is a scary statistic ("Grey's Anatomy" had a pregnant man in one episode for crying out loud!), these shows can be used as a public health tool, some experts have said. “Not only are they reaching to more people, they’re getting through to them and having an impact,” said Vicky Rideout, director of the Kaiser Family Foundation’s Program for the Study of Entertainment Media and Health, at the Association of Health Care Journalists conference I recently attended. (AHCJ's site has a podcast and webcast of the entertainment and health round table if you would like to learn more.) The Kaiser Family Foundation surveyed "ER" viewers about what they learned from the show before and after episodes came out. Viewer recognition of HPV, the virus that can cause cervical cancer, almost doubled after a short vignette on the show in 2000 in which nurse Carol Hathaway explains to a teenage patient that her cervical cancer could be related to the virus. The survey found that 24 percent of viewers had heard of HPV before the episode. One week after the episode, this grew to 47 percent, and five weeks later this leveled off at 38 percent. Similarly, awareness of emergency contraception went from 50 percent before the episode to 67 percent after the episode. The entire vignette, which was part of an "ER" episode that aired April 10, 1997, lasted almost three minutes with the discussion about emergency contraception lasting only 20 seconds. I guess I can see this. As an avid fan of a lot of these shows, I often have those "Wow, I think I just learned something" moments. After having the light bulb go off over my head, I usually tell myself to look up what I just learned later to verify if it's true. (Like "abulia," which a woman was afflicted with in last week's "House." This is a true condition, by the way. "House" characterized it as a lack of free will. MedlinePlus' medical dictionary defines it as an "abnormal lack of ability to act or to make decisions that is characteristic of certain psychotic and neurotic conditions." House's version sounds much more interesting, though.) But unfortunately, I usually forget to do this a few minutes after telling myself to. How much do you trust the health information on these shows? Have you learned anything from them? Have you ever consulted a doctor about a condition you learned about on a medical TV show? 4 comments from 4 users
1
posted by
possummomma
on Apr 30, 2007 at 12:21 PM
It's difficult for me to be impartial, but I think that, with regard to House, people DO need to remember that it is a television show. The clinic vignettes are a useful tool, in that they show how people can over or underestimate their own sense of reason and common sense. I mean, it should be common sense that a child rocking, grunting, and sweating, but happy, in a car seat is probably not epilepsy...but, just a girl saying "Yoo hoo to the hoo hoo." Or, that red rash might come from lying, after a bath, on a new red sofa. Conversely, performing an adult circumcision with box cutters...probably a bad idea. As for the diseases that House treats as the PotW (patient of the week)... I think it's important for the general public to remember that "time is not a fixed construct" (on House) and that these aren't your normal patients. While there are lessons to be learned, the maladies on HOUSE are not supposed to be taken as frequently occurring events. They are the zebras of medicine. No one should rely on medical information gleaned from a sit-com or television drama. The goal of these shows is to entertain first and... if some education falls through in the process, great. But, it's not meant to be a substitute for individual responsibility or common sense. :)
posted by
TomW
on Apr 30, 2007 at 12:27 PM
posted by
randomfactor
on Apr 30, 2007 at 12:27 PM
To me, House is the medical version of "Law & Order." In the first 15 minutes, we learn what the patient's problem is. In the next 15, we learn why that's not really his problem. In the next 15, we figure out what really *IS* the problem. In the last 15, we find out why what his real problem is, looked like what we were almost positive his problem was... posted by
steveeswenson
on May 1, 2007 at 01:29 PM
I don't do that because I'm far too sweet. But as for the medical stuff, it's way too complicated for me but the show is great entertainment anyway.
1
Our readers recommend: |